Andre Agassi defeated Ivo Karlovic 7-6 7-6 7-6 in the US Open round of 64 on hard.
Agassi A. took it in straight sets.
Agassi A. and Karlovic I. faced 3 of the same opponents in the last 12 months. Agassi A. went 2–1 (67%) against them, Karlovic I. 0–4 (0%). Agassi A. came out better against 2 of 3 comparable opponents, Karlovic I. against 0 — though 1 of those edges carries caveats (retirement).
Only 3 common opponents — small sample, treat as indicative.
Andre Agassi beat Ivo Karlovic 7-6 7-6 7-6. Umpiry, "Andre Agassi vs Ivo Karlovic — US Open Round of 64", https://umpiry.com/match/2005-08-29/agassi-vs-karlovic-us-open-r64?utm_source=cite (as of 29 August 2005).